Anchovies On Pizza

Anchovies on pizza are a divisive yet flavorful addition that can elevate the taste of this classic dish. Anchovies bring a rich umami flavor and a briny saltiness to pizza, enhancing its overall taste profile. Whether you prefer the traditional Napoli style with capers and olives or a lighter version with lemons and onions, anchovies can be a star ingredient that adds depth to the pizza. 

The curing process of anchovies transforms them into a potent source of flavor, making them a versatile ingredient that can be added to various dishes beyond pizza. When preparing anchovy pizza, it’s essential to find high-quality anchovies, such as those from the Mediterranean packed in salt, to ensure the best flavor experience. 

Whether you choose to add anchovies whole or sliced, incorporating them into the pizza before baking allows their flavor to meld with the sauce and other toppings, creating a delicious and savory outcome. So, whether you are a fan of anchovies or looking to explore new flavors, anchovies on pizza can be a delightful culinary experience that adds a unique and delicious twist to this beloved dish.

Anchovy On Pizza

Anchovy pizza is a popular Italian pizza topping that provides a savory, umami flavor. Here is a summary of the key information about anchovy pizza from the search results:

Anchovy pizza is considered one of the most popular Italian pizza recipes. The salty, savory flavor of anchovies pairs well with the other classic pizza toppings like tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, olives, onions, and herbs.

To make a delicious anchovy pizza, it’s important to use high-quality ingredients. The search results recommend using:

  • Fresh, homemade or store-bought pizza dough
  • Flavorful tomato sauce, ideally from Italian tomatoes
  • Fresh, high-quality mozzarella cheese (not too much to avoid a soggy crust)
  • Whole anchovy fillets packed in olive oil, not skinny or mushy anchovies
  • Other toppings like olives, onions, capers, lemon, and fresh herbs
  • The key is to let the pizza dough rise properly, gently stretch it without a rolling pin, and bake at a very high temperature (around 425-550°F) to get a crispy, puffy crust that can stand up to the bold anchovy flavor.

Some variations on anchovy pizza include using a white sauce instead of tomato, adding roasted red peppers or pineapple, or using ricotta cheese as a base. But the classic combination of tomato, mozzarella, and anchovies is considered one of the most delicious and authentic Italian pizza toppings.

What Are Anchovies On Pizza?

What Are Anchovies On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza are a classic and divisive topping. Here is a summary of the key points about anchovies on pizza:

Anchovies are small, salty, and savory fish that have been used as a pizza topping since the 16th century in Naples, Italy.They have a strong, umami-rich flavor that can be polarizing – some love it, while others find it overpowering.

When used properly, anchovies can add a delicious depth of flavor to pizza. They go through an extensive curing process that makes them salty, fruity, and intensely savory.The best anchovies come from the Mediterranean and are packed in salt or oil.

To use anchovies on pizza, it’s recommended to break up the fillets and scatter them over the top of the pizza after it comes out of the oven.This allows the anchovies to melt and incorporate into the pie without becoming overpowering.

Pairing the anchovies with tomato sauce and cheese helps balance the saltiness.

Anchovies are also a nutritious topping, providing omega-3 fatty acids, protein, and other vitamins and minerals.

However, they are high in sodium, so those with certain health conditions may need to limit their intake.

Overall, anchovies can be a delicious and unique pizza topping, but they are a polarizing ingredient. Whether you love them or hate them, they are a classic Italian pizza topping with a long history.

Anchovies On Pizza Recipe

Here is a concise answer to the question based on the search results:

Anchovies are a popular and flavorful pizza topping that can be enjoyed in a variety of ways. Some key tips for making delicious anchovy pizza include:

  • Use high-quality cured anchovies packed in oil rather than water for maximum flavor.
  • Pair the anchovies with complementary toppings like onions, lemon, capers, olives, parsley, or basil.
  • You can add the anchovies whole on top of the pizza, or blend them into the tomato sauce for a more subtle umami flavor.
  • Other tasty ingredient combinations include ricotta cheese, roasted red peppers, garlic, chicken, or pineapple.
  • Bake the pizza at a high temperature (around 425-500°F) to get a crispy crust that balances the salty, savory anchovies.

The search results provide several specific anchovy pizza recipes and techniques to try at home. With the right toppings and cooking methods, anchovies can make for a delicious and unique pizza experience.

Anchovies On Pizza Papa Johns

Papa John’s does offer anchovies as a pizza topping, but the availability and ordering process can vary by location.

Some key points:

Anchovies are listed as a topping option on Papa John’s website, but individual locations may choose not to offer them.

Customers have reported that even if anchovies are not listed online, they can sometimes request them and the store will accommodate the order.

The process of ordering anchovies can be complicated, as some stores may not want to open a can just for one order. Customers have had to call the store directly and request the anchovies be added.

Once an anchovy order is placed, the store may provide the customer with a whole can of anchovies rather than having them pre-cooked on the pizza. This requires the customer to prepare the anchovies themselves.

The availability and handling of anchovies seem to vary significantly by Papa John’s location, leading to an inconsistent customer experience.

In summary, while Papa John’s does offer anchovies, the ability to order them and have them properly prepared on a pizza can be challenging and dependent on the individual store’s policies and practices.

Are Anchovies Good On Pizza?

Are Anchovies Good On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza can be a divisive topic, with some people loving them and others not so much. The unique flavor of anchovies, known for their brininess and umami qualities, can elevate a pizza to new heights. While 24% of pizza eaters enjoy anchovies, 76% prefer to steer clear of them. Anchovies pair well with certain toppings like Calabrian chiles, capers, garlic, tomatoes, and sausage, enhancing the overall flavor profile of the pizza. 

Additionally, anchovies are not only flavorful but also packed with health benefits, being rich in protein, iron, and omega-3s, which support heart health. Ultimately, whether anchovies are good on pizza comes down to personal preference, but they can add a unique and delicious twist to this classic dish.

What Do Anchovies Taste Like On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza are known for their distinctive salty and fruity flavor profile. The salty taste is often described as intense, while the fruity note adds a subtle sweetness to balance it out. The combination of these flavors creates a unique and savory taste experience that is both addictive and polarizing, with some people loving the taste and others strongly disliking it.

What Goes Well With Anchovies On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza are a classic combination that can be paired with a variety of toppings to enhance their unique flavor profile. Here are some popular and recommended pairings:

Onion: A classic combination, of anchovies, and onions creates a savory and slightly sweet flavor profile.

Mushroom: The earthy flavor of mushrooms complements the salty, umami taste of anchovies, making for a well-rounded pizza.

Fresh Jalapenos: For a spicy kick, adding fresh jalapenos to an anchovy pizza can create a bold and exciting flavor combination.

Fennel: Fennel’s anise flavor pairs well with the brininess of anchovies, making for a unique and tasty combination.

Olives: Anchovies and olives share a similar salty flavor profile, which can create a harmonious and savory pizza.

Broccoli: While not a traditional pairing, broccoli’s mild bitterness can balance out the strong flavor of anchovies, making for a well-rounded pizza.

Calabrian Chiles: These Italian peppers add a spicy kick and a smoky flavor that complements the anchovies well.

Capers: Capers’ salty, tangy flavor can enhance the umami taste of anchovies, creating a rich and savory pizza.

Garlic: Anchovies and garlic are a classic combination, with garlic’s pungency balancing out the strong flavor of anchovies.

Tomatoes: Fresh tomatoes can add a touch of sweetness to balance out the saltiness of anchovies, creating a well-rounded pizza.

Sausage: For a meatier pizza, anchovies pair well with sausage, creating a rich and savory combination.

Fresh Parsley or Basil: Adding fresh herbs like parsley or basil can add a bright and refreshing flavor to balance out the strong taste of anchovies.

What Goes With Anchovies On Pizza?

Anchovies pair well with a variety of toppings on pizza.

 Some complementary ingredients include:

  • Olives, both black and kalamata, which add a briny, salty flavor.
  • Capers, which provide a tangy, piquant note.
  • Thinly sliced red onions, which balance the saltiness of the anchovies.
  • Tomato sauce, which helps temper the strong anchovy flavor.
  • Mozzarella cheese, which creates a creamy contrast.
  • Basil or parsley, which adds freshness.
  • Lemon slices can brighten the overall pizza.

The key is to use high-quality anchovies and balance their intense umami taste with other flavorful toppings.

 With the right combination, anchovies can be a delicious and complementary pizza topping.

Anchovies On Pizza Near Me

Anchovies are a common pizza topping, though they can be quite salty. Some tips for enjoying anchovies on pizza:

  • Anchovies used to be very popular as a pizza topping, but the saltiness can be overpowering if not used properly.
  • To reduce the saltiness, try mashing the anchovies into a paste and mixing them into olive oil before drizzling over the pizza.
  • Anchovies pair well with other salty toppings like olives, capers, and garlic.
  • Many pizza places will allow you to request “hold the anchovies” if you don’t want them.
  • Anchovies are a good source of omega-3s, protein, and nutrients, so they can be a healthy pizza topping in moderation.

Anchovies On Pizza Domain_10

Anchovies On Pizza Domain_10

Anchovies can be a delicious and flavorful topping for pizza. When used properly, they can add a savory, umami-rich taste to the pie. However, anchovies have a strong, pungent flavor that some people dislike, especially if they are overcooked. The key is to use high-quality, cured anchovies and add them to the pizza after it comes out of the oven so they don’t become overpowering. 

Anchovies are a good source of omega-3 fatty acids, protein, and various vitamins and minerals, making them a nutritious pizza topping.

While anchovies are not as popular as other toppings like pepperoni, they can be a delicious and unique addition to a homemade 10 Inch Pizza.

Sardines Vs Anchovies On Pizza

Here is a table comparing the use of sardines and anchovies on pizza:

FlavorMild, less fishyStrong, very fishy
TextureFirm, flakySoft, melt into the pizza
AppearanceLarger, more visible piecesSmaller, can melt into the pizza
Common UsesTopping added to saucesTopping, added to sauces, blended into the pizza
AdvantagesProvide a more subtle seafood flavorAdd a bold, salty umami flavor
DisadvantagesMay be overpowered by other toppingsCan be overwhelming if used excessively
Recommended UseFor those who want a light seafood taste on their pizzaFor those who enjoy a strong anchovy flavor on their pizza

The key differences are that sardines have a milder, less fishy flavor compared to the strong, salty umami taste of anchovies. Sardines also have a firmer, flakier texture while anchovies can melt into the pizza. Both can be used as toppings or incorporated into sauces, but anchovies tend to be the more polarizing choice for pizza due to their intense flavor.

What Do Anchovies On Pizza Taste Like?

Anchovies on pizza have a distinct salty and savory flavor. The curing process gives them a fruity and umami taste that can elevate the overall pizza experience.

When used in moderation, anchovies provide a burst of flavor that complements the other ingredients on the pizza. However, too many anchovies can make the pizza overly salty and overwhelm the other flavors. The key is to find a balance and use high-quality anchovies that have been properly cured and prepared.

What Goes With Anchovies On A Pizza?

Anchovies on a pizza pair well with ingredients that complement their strong, salty flavor. Consider adding ingredients like olives, capers, garlic, and onions to enhance the taste of anchovies. These additions provide a balance of flavors and textures that work harmoniously with the distinct taste of anchovies.

For a more adventurous twist, try combining anchovies with ingredients like fresh tomatoes, arugula, or even a drizzle of balsamic glaze. These additions can add a burst of freshness and acidity that cuts through the richness of the anchovies, creating a delicious and well-rounded pizza experience. Experimenting with different combinations can lead to discovering unique and delightful flavor profiles that elevate the classic anchovy pizza.

Are Anchovies On Pizza Good

Anchovies on pizza are a controversial topic, but they can be a delightful addition if prepared well. These small, salty fish are cured to develop a unique flavor profile that adds a burst of umami to the pizza. Despite the initial fishy smell, anchovies on pizza offer a salty and fruity taste that complements the tomato and cheese, creating a flavorful experience. Additionally, anchovies are a good source of Omega 3 fats and protein, making them not only tasty but also nutritious. So, if you’re open to trying new toppings, anchovies on pizza might surprise you with their delicious and savory taste.

In summary, anchovies on pizza can be a flavorful and healthy choice, offering a unique umami taste that enhances the overall pizza experience. While some may be hesitant due to the fishy reputation of anchovies, their salty and fruity flavor can truly elevate the pizza, providing a burst of flavors that blend well with other ingredients like tomato and cheese. So, next time you’re feeling adventurous with your pizza toppings, consider giving anchovies a try for a delicious and nutritious twist to your pizza night.

Anchovies On Pizza Origin

Anchovies on pizza have a long history dating back to the 16th century when the people of Naples introduced them as a topping due to their abundance and sustainability. The original Italian pizza included anchovies paired with tomatoes, a combination that helped balance the saltiness of the fish. Anchovies were a common choice for pizza toppings in Italy, especially among peasants who favored affordable and long-lasting ingredients, making them a traditional and widespread addition to early pizzas.

The tradition of anchovies on pizza continued as Italians immigrated to the United States, bringing their culinary heritage with them. Over time, anchovies on pizza became less popular among non-Italians, leading to a divisive reputation for this topping. Despite being considered controversial, anchovies remain a classic ingredient in pizza history, reflecting the evolution of pizza toppings and tastes over the years.

What Are Some Other Toppings That Go Well With Anchovies On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza pair well with a variety of toppings to enhance their unique flavor. Some excellent choices include capers for an extra salty kick, garlic for a flavorful punch, tomatoes for a balanced sweetness, sausage for a luxurious touch, and Calabrian chiles for a spicy twist. 

These toppings complement the brininess and umami qualities of anchovies, creating a delicious and harmonious combination on your pizza. Additionally, ingredients like onions, lemon, olives, fresh herbs like parsley or basil, marinara sauce, and even ricotta cheese can further elevate the taste of anchovies on pizza, offering a diverse range of flavors to suit different preferences.

How To Prepare Anchovies For Pizza?

How To Prepare Anchovies For Pizza?

Anchovies are a popular pizza topping that can add a savory, umami flavor to your pie. However, preparing them properly is important to ensure they don’t overpower the other ingredients. Here’s a simple guide on how to prepare anchovies for your pizza.

Rinse and Drain the Anchovies

Start by rinsing the anchovies under cold water to remove any excess salt or brine. Gently pat them dry with a paper towel or clean cloth. This will help prevent the anchovies from making your pizza too salty or overpowering the other flavors.

Chop or Mince the Anchovies

Once the anchovies are clean and dry, you can chop or mince them into small pieces. This will help distribute the flavor more evenly across the pizza. You can use a sharp knife or kitchen shears to do this. Aim for pieces that are about the size of a pea or smaller.

What Are Some Variations Of Anchovy Pizza?

 Anchovy pizza is a classic Italian dish that can be enjoyed in a variety of ways. 

One popular variation is the Pizza Napoli, which is a Margherita pizza topped with anchovies and capers.  Another option is to use a white sauce instead of a tomato-based sauce, which can pair well with the salty, umami flavor of the anchovies.  

Toppings like fresh tomatoes, bell peppers, spinach, arugula, or artichokes can also be added to create a more complex flavor profile.  Some people even enjoy the controversial combination of anchovies and pineapple. No matter the toppings, the key is to balance the saltiness of the anchovies with other flavors and textures.


What Does Anchovies Taste Like On Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza have a salty and fruity taste, with a strong umami flavor that intensifies other ingredients. The taste is often described as garlicky and savory, with a burst of flavors in each bite.

What Goes Good With Anchovies On A Pizza?

Anchovies on pizza pair well with bold flavors like olives, capers, and garlic. These ingredients complement the salty, umami taste of anchovies for a delicious combination.

What Toppings Go With Anchovies On Pizza?

Anchovies pair well with olives, capers, and red onions on pizza. These toppings complement the salty and savory flavor of anchovies perfectly.


Anchovies can be a delicious addition to pizza, but they’re not for everyone. If you’re a fan of the salty, savory flavor, give them a try. If not, there are plenty of other tasty toppings to choose from.

Question: Are anchovies a common pizza topping?

Answer: Anchovies are a relatively common pizza topping, though not as popular as some other toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms. They are a divisive ingredient, with some people loving the salty, umami flavor they add to pizza, while others find them overpowering. Anchovies have been used as a pizza topping for a long time, with their use dating back to the origins of pizza in Italy.

Leave a Comment